Equipment: 30in Blowdown Piping System of Coke Drum in Severe Thermal Cycling & High Temperature Service

Problem:The circumferential weld located between the two forged tees of the connecting 20in & 10in branch lines, on the 30in Blow down header had witnessed a through wall crack repeatedly on two occasions since the blow down header was put into operation. The crack formation and propagation indicates that the failure mode was fatigue.

Thermocouple Data
5b-1
Circum therm stress-At top

Benefits: Upon implementation of the upgraded design consisting of utilizing sweepolets, smooth-contoured weld profiles and revised piping configurations, the repetitive failures of the coker blowdown piping were eliminated resulting in uninterrupted coking operations.

Analysis: The objective of the fatigue failure analysis is to determine the allowable life cycles & cumulative damage occurred at the circumferential weld located between the two forged tees of the connecting branch lines  based on the the fatigue design curves and the stress cycles generated during ONE operational cycle. The one complete operational cycle corresponded to 24hrs and involves the coking cycle, of each of the three Coker sets of  successively. The operational load combination was applied in a time based manner, such that the operational cycle from start to end (24hrs) is covered. The thermal gradient that gives rise to cyclic stresses is transient in reality. This evaluation requires applying an accurate transient thermal gradient to arrive at the true nature of the stress cycles generated thereof. However, this can be possible by completing a CFD (or knowing the temperature profile accurately enough i.e. 0F/12inches), and then applying the temperature gradient to the solid model as a function of time, resulting in stress cycles. Hence for the purpose of simplification, the following method of loading was adopted to generate the Thermal cyclical loadings As the type of temperature loading witnessed by the BlowDown header is Extremely Complex for this purpose the complete thermal loading of the BD header has been broken down into simpler but realistic scenarios, which individually but independently generate their respective Type and Number of stress cycles. The main objective is to identify all those operational instants, which could lead to Stress extremes that follow every Stress reversal For a temperature loading, it is the thermal swing at which the stress reversal occurs immediately following a stress extreme.

Longit thermal grad

Results Conclusion:A comparison was made between the stress intensity cycle characteristics of the following cyclical loads, and conclusions were as follows. Piping expansion loading (General thermal load) produces the most severe range of stress intensity, which in turn decides the most conservative 'Number of cycles' to failure. Circumferential thermal gradient (Local thermal load causing thermal bowing), as compared to the piping expansion load, produces only 10% as effective a range of stress intensity. Longitudinal thermal gradient (Local thermal load causing thermal bowing), as compared to the piping expansion load, produces only 6% as effective a range of stress intensity. The alternating stress intensity range for both, is well below the endurance limit of TEE/Weld material; hence this location can sustain infinite number of operational cycles without contributing to the fatigue damage. Thus all the weak locations that were succeptible to fatigue failures were identified as per this analysis, which basically laid the foundation of preparing the structural upgrade scope of work.

Circumferential thermal grad
Home   Pressure Vessels Failure Analysis   Heat Exchangers Failure Analysis   Fired Heaters Failure Analysis   API Crude Natural Gas Storage Tanks - Failures   Chemical Plant Refinery Process Piping Systems Pipelines - Failures   Flanged Joints Gaskets Bolts of Piping - Leakage Failures in Service   Assessments   Contact Us